When comparing LP SmartSide to fiber cement (such as James Hardie), LP SmartSide is generally the more budget-friendly and economical option both upfront and over time. Estimates for the Denver metro area show a significant price difference:

• LP SmartSide: Costs approximately $4–7 per sq ft installed.
• Fiber Cement: Costs approximately $8–12 per sq ft installed.

This makes LP SmartSide nearly 50% less expensive to install than fiber cement. Several factors contribute to this cost difference:

1. Labor and Installation: LP SmartSide is lighter and easier to cut, which reduces labor time and complexity. Fiber cement is heavier and requires specialized cutting tools, leading to higher labor costs.
2. Maintenance: While fiber cement may require less frequent painting (every 15+ years for some finishes compared to 10–15 years for SmartSide), the significantly lower initial investment for SmartSide often provides a better total return on investment.
3. Repair Costs: Because LP SmartSide features superior hail resistance and a Class 4 impact rating, it is less likely to crack or shatter during storms compared to brittle fiber cement. this can lead to lower long-term repair expenses and potentially reduced insurance costs.